Gray hats

I recently watched the first season of the BBC series “Sherlock,” a modern-take on the Arthur Conan Doyle stories.  (Two disclaimers – I have not seen season two of the series, but wouldn’t recommend it based on a few things I’ve heard, and I’ve never seen the Robert Downey, Jr movies, so I don’t know how they compare.)  I found the series highly entertaining, especially for avid Holmes fans, who will notice many clever tributes to the original stories.  It was intriguing to see how the writers adapted not just the characters (Watson, for example, was wounded in modern Afghanistan, just as the Doyle has him wounded there in the Second Anglo-Afghan War, but he blogs about Holmes’ escapades instead of publishing them) but also the small details of the cases (Holmes surmises someone is an alcoholic — not because their pocketwatch is scratched where an unsteady hand wound it every night, but because their cell phone is scratched where an unsteady hand plugged it into the charger).  While the homosexual jokes got old, I found the three episodes, on the whole, quite enjoyable.

They did inspire me to re-read the original stories, something I haven’t done yet but hope to soon.  One thing I’d like to investigate are the character traits of Holmes. In the BBC series, he is odd, rude, and conceited.  Was he always like this?  Did I just manage to look the other way?  I always really liked Sherlock Holmes… was I blind to his personality?  How much of this Holmes was the product of the writers’ interpretation and how much was authentic?

By the third episode, my hero was no hero at all.  He saved lives and outsmarted criminals and his eccentricity was strangely charismatic.  He had grown on me.  But a man in a white hat, he was not.  And then he admitted himself:

“Don’t make people into heroes, John. Heroes don’t exist and if they did I wouldn’t be one of them.”

How depressing.

That led me to ponder the rise of the antihero.  I remember reading an article after the release of Spiderman 2 that bemoaned that fact that even our superheroes had become melodramatic and fickle.  Peter Parker was going emo on us, wondering if he should still be Spiderman.  Superman Returns gave us another emo superhero that lacked a little super and that almost lost Lois to James Marsden.  What was the world coming to?

It’s nothing new, of course – antiheroes have been with us in literature for quite some time.  But these days they seem to dominate the landscape.  The larger-than-life, white-hat-wearing heroes seem almost non-existent in television and movies, and coupled with the fact that they seem less prevalent in real life, too, the antihero seems to be the best we can do.

I know some will say it’s art imitating life.  We live in a fallen world, and it’s not realistic to have sinless, irreproachable characters.

But golly, can’t we have something to strive for?  Maybe every father isn’t Ward Cleaver.  But every father isn’t Al Bundy, either.  I think our lives could use a little more Mr. Cunningham and Dr. Huxtable. (This is an interesting look at the way television father’s have changed since the days of Mr. Cleaver: Ten TV Dads, chronologically)

What’s wrong with holding someone up as a model – a hero-  someone we can really emulate?  When my favorite character from a current BBC show fell last Sunday, I almost threw something at the television.  Until now, he had been strong, wise, and loving while his world was at war (literally).  He had shown compassion to servants, love to his wife, constancy amidst strife, humor and patience with the six women in his life.  He seemed to be the rock, the one who held the world together.

But he’s only human, the show’s creators seemed to want to show us.

Oh, so it’s too much to expect all that from a man?  Strength, love, wisdom, constancy, compassion, humor, patience.  That’s not realistic?

What a sad view of the world.

Bring back the white hat, and maybe some men will rise up to be worthy of it.


4 thoughts on “Gray hats

  1. Amy says:

    Ok, I should be asleep instead of writing this, so sorry if I’m unclear in what I’m about to say. I absolutely agree with you that we have far too many Al Bundys and “heroes” that don’t live up to the term. But I took the whole Peter Parker thing (never having read the actual comic books, and only seeing movies 1 & 2) as a sort of “God chooses the weak and makes them strong.” I know I often doubt my ability to do what must be done…and that’s because by myself I CAN’T do what must be done. If any of us are going to do the impossible, or live heroically, we must have God’s grace, and as we’re growing to trust God’s grace we can struggle with an awful lot of doubt (self- or otherwise). I know, God didn’t come into the picture in SpiderMan, so maybe I read too much into it. Or maybe I’m forgetting some key downfall of his. But that was my takeaway…on that superhero, anyway
    But that said, I’ve thrown many an object at the screen when the hero fell from grace…

  2. Haus Frau says:

    Bring on Mr. Darcy.

    As much as people make fun of Austen’s predictability, her heroes were mostly heroes. If they made a mistake, she didn’t extol it. My only complaint is that she didn’t make Edmund Bertram suffer NEARLY enough in “Mansfield Park.”

    (Sorry, I know they’re not super-heroes, but that’s my two cents).

  3. Mom says:

    If I want reality, I will watch Fox news. I don’t want to watch heros fall on tv series. I want to see virtue if I am going to invest my time. But virtue doesn’t sell. So I don’t watch tv series/movies, any of it. I would rather read a book. Maybe it’s my age. Of course it’s my age! Haha! I have seen it all and don’t care to see any more of it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s